Thursday, June 17, 2010

Adaptation Science and Policy in Developing Countries:

Adaptation Science and Policy in Developing Countries: Three lessons learned and preconceptions unlearned

By
Saleemul Huq
Senior Fellow
International Institute for Environment and Development(IIED)

Speech delivered at the
Adaptation Knowledge Day
Bonn, Germany
7 June 2010

First let me thank the organisers for inviting me to speak at this event. Having started the first “Adaptation Day at the COP” event in COP8 in Delhi, India back in 2002, when the number of people interested in adaptation attending the UNFCCC COP could easily fit within a single small room, it is wonderful to see so many more people being engaged on adaptation since then and it is timely that UNEP, UNFCCC, World Bank have decided to hold an Adaptation “Knowledge” Day-which I hope will be repeated at each UNFCCC meeting.
However despite the growing interest in adaptation science and policy that has grown rapidly over the last few years, the science and policy-making on adaptation (unlike mitigation which has a decade-long head start over adaptation) remains very young and we still have a steep learning curve ahead of us.
Having been involved in this young science of adaptation from its early period, I would like to share some early lessons that have already become apparent. I will characterise them as: “Three lessons learned and pre-conceptions unlearned”.
The first lesson is that there are (at least) four, equally important groups who need to be involved in both the learning as well as doing adaptation, namely, the researchers (doing the “science”), the policy-makers (both at global as well as national levels), the planners (particularly at various sectoral levels, such as coastal managements, water management , etc) and the practitioners (including many civil society groups as well as communities and households ).
Thus the first preconception that needs to be unlearned is that studying and learning about adaptation (unlike impacts and vulnerability) can be achieved simply by researchers doing “analysis” or “theory” alone. It needs to be done by “learning-by-doing”. This requires a shift in the prevailing paradigm of research which pre-supposes that researchers carry out research on their own and publish their findings to be then read and used by policy-makers and practitioners-to a genuine collaboration between researchers and policy-makers , planners and/or practitioners. Such collaborative arrangements to “co-learn” will require researchers to come out of their comfort zone and initiate such collaborative arrangements with others.
The second lesson learned is that planning adaptation at the national level has only just begun in a small number of countries. However, the countries that first started planning exercises (through the national adaptation plans of action or NAPAs) were the forty-eight least developed countries (LDCs) while other countries (including the developed countries) are only just starting national adaptation plans. Thus the early learning on adaptation science, policy-making and planning is happening in some of the poorest countries (and communities) on the planet and the rich countries may need to learn from them.
This leads us to the second pre-conception that needs to be unlearned, namely that global knowledge is generated in the richer countries and is then transferred to the poorer countries. When it comes to adapting to the adverse impacts of climate change the rich can learn from the poor.
The third lesson learned is that adaptation to climate change is very closely linked (in practice) to (sustainable) development. This had led to early efforts at adaptation being linked to disaster risk reduction (DRR) for climate related disasters such as droughts, floods and hurricanes. While this makes logical sense to start from experience already gained in adaptation to such climate variation in the past, the new dimension (which is only just being explored) is to factor in our knowledge and information on possible future climate impacts due to human induced climate change.
Thus the third pre-conception to be unlearned is that all we need to do adaptation is better climate models and climate information. While having these is certainly desirable they are no longer essential.
Finally, let me share some early activities about linking science to both policy-making as well as practice that is happening at the level of the most vulnerable communities on the planet, namely the Community Based Adaptation (CBA) to Climate Change.
Over the last few years a number of researchers, policy-makers and practitioners have been holding a series of meetings on CBA to share early experience and learning. The first three meetings were held in Bangladesh two-years apart, in 2005, 2007 and 2009. At the third meeting in 2009 the group (which had grown to over 100 people from all over the world) decided to form a lose consortium called the Global Initiative on CBA (GICBA) and to make the meeting an annual event with every second one being held in Bangladesh.
Thus the next (4th) CBA conference was held in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania in February 2010 with around 180 participants and the next (5th) one will be held again in Bangladesh from 2 to 8 February 2011. In the meantime a website for CBA has been established (http://community.eldis.org/cbax/ and a CBA layer on Google Earth is under development.
This represents one attempt to link researchers with policy-makers, planners and practitioners in order to help adaptation efforts for the most vulnerable communities.
Let me conclude by saying that I feel that we are entering a phase of letting “a hundred flowers bloom” on both research and actions on adaptation. The challenge for the “knowledge” community is to effectively share that learning in real time and feedback to all the actors as fast as possible. The flow of lessons learned from research to practice and policy will have to be done at much greater speed when it comes to adaptation as we have no time to lose. I commend the Adaptation Knowledge Day for making an important contribution in this respect.
Thank you.

No comments:

Post a Comment